Mystery of the 13th Guest (1943)


What is the mystery of the empty 13th chair?

vt The Mystery of the 13th Guest
US / 61 minutes / bw / Monogram Dir: William Beaudine Pr: Lindsley Parsons Scr: Tim Ryan, Charles Marion, Arthur Hoerl Story: The Thirteenth Guest (1929) by Armitage Trail Cine: Mack Stengler Cast: Helen Parrish, Dick Purcell, Tim Ryan, Frank Faylen, Jacqueline Dalya, Paul McVey, John Duncan, Jon Dawson, Cyril Ring, Addison Richards, Lloyd Ingraham, Fred “Snowflake” Toones, Shirley Jean Anderson, Lester Dorr, Herbert Heyes.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 1 The mystery envelope ...

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 1a ... and what it contained

Thirteen years ago, in the old Morgan home at 122 Mill Road, Grandpa Morgan (Ingraham) convoked a meeting of his ten possible heirs, plus his lawyer, John Barksdale (Ring). The twelve of them sat around a table at which a 13th chair remained empty—the nonexistent “13th guest” of the title, even though this would be technically not the 13th but the 12th guest. Grandpa announced that his will was contained in a sealed envelope, which he passed to his seven-year-old granddaughter, Marie (Anderson), on condition that she open it on her 21st birthday while seated at this very table.

Fast forward to today, as one dark night the grown-up Marie Morgan (Parrish) lets herself into the old family heap. She’s astonished to find that, even though the place has been closed up for thirteen years, the phone and electricity are still on. In the gloom a shot rings out and, the next we know, Marie falls to the ground, dead, electrocuted by a gimmicked telephone. By the time the cops get there, roused by the taxi driver (uncredited) who brought her here, her oddly lifelike corpse has been sat in the very chair she occupied all those years ago.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 2 Barksdale arrives to search the joint

Barksdale (Cyril Ring) arrives to search the joint.

Since Parrish is the headline star, it’s not exactly a surprise to discover that it wasn’t Marie who died at all—just her duplicate. We never do discover the identity of the electrocuted woman; she seems simply to have been some pawn hired to undergo a reboot at the hands of plastic surgeon Dr. Sherwood (Hayes). For that matter, we never discover the significance of the empty 13th chair. That the empty chair and the missing diner were important was foreshadowed right at the outset by Grandpa, but that’s about as much as we ever learn on this front.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 3 The Mystery Man prepares to electrocute his second victim

 The Mystery Man prepares to electrocute his second victim.

Police Lieutenant Burke (Ryan, who also co-scripted) finds himself with a whole gamut of other Morgan kith and kindred, guests at that long-ago dinner, including Marie’s brother Harold “Bud” Morgan (Duncan), her cousin Tom Jackson (Dawson), her viperous sister Marjory (Dalya)—says Marie at one point, “Marjory, dear, your soul must look like the inside of a vinegar bottle”—and her kindly Uncle Adam (McVey). The latter is the one who earlier worriedly hired a local PI, Johnny Smith (Purcell), to safeguard his beloved niece Marie.

Johnny quickly deduces that the murderer plans to repopulate the dining table with the eleven surviving occupants from Grandpa’s dinner—albeit now in stiff form. Why he should wish to follow this regime remains unexplained by movie’s end, as does the plan itself—just like, as we’ve noted, so much else.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 4 Marie tries to phone lawyer, not realizing danger

Marie (Helen Parrish) tries to call the lawyer, not realizing the danger of using the telephone.

Burke is a central-casting version of the type of laughing-stock cop that Hollywood thought was thigh-slappingly hilarious through the 1930s and much of the 1940s. Just to make matters even more cringeworthy, Burke has a sidekick who’s even stupider and more incompetent than he is himself: the narcoleptic Speed McGinnis (Faylen), the delight of whose comedy routines could be increased only decades later with the invention of the remote control and fast forward.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 7 Speed is easily bamboozled by the alluring Marjory

Speed McGinnis (Frank Faylen) is easily bamboozled by the alluring Marjory (Jacqueline Dalya).

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 5 Uncle Adam, Jilly Smith, Marie

Uncle Adam (Paul McVey), Johnny Smith (Dick Purcell) and Marie (Helen Parrish).

Mystery of the 13th Guest is an anachronistic oddity for 1943 in that it reads like a child of the mid-1930s. The mid-1940s were the era when gangster movies and what would later be called film noir dominated the US output of B crime cinema. By the later mid-1940s even the THIN MAN MOVIES were becoming more noirish, with Song of the Thin Man (1947). The Frankie Darro/Mantan Moreland movies, in which Moreland was constrained to render a rolling-eyed inferior to his white costar, ran just from 1939 to 1941 before it was recognized that their course had run; here, in 1943, we see the admirable Fred “Snowflake” Toones produce a reasonable imitation of Moreland in the role of Johnny Smith’s manservant. The telephone rigged to electrocute people was featured for possibly the first time in Edgar Wallace’s serialized novel The Four Just Men in 1905; I’ve no idea if the movie got it from Armitrage Trail’s source novel (I haven’t been able as yet to locate a copy) or nicked it from Wallace’s but, either way, as a gimmick it’s old news. In short, while we don’t expect a product of the Monogram studio to be at the cutting edge of film noir, at the same time the studio was not at all unaware of the new style, and frequently catered to it, albeit often ineptly. There’s no sign of that awareness here; everything seems dated.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 8 Marjory hauled by killer into his secret lair

Marjory (Jacqueline Dalya) is hauled by the killer into his secret lair.

Interestingly, Edward J. Kay’s intermittently frenetic score seems to be urging us to regard Mystery of the 13th Guest not as a crime/mystery movie at all but as a melodrama, and maybe that was the intention of director Beaudine and producer Parsons. The secret room from which the murderer views and electrocutes his victims, and the mask that he wears, would certainly feed into that hypothesis, as would the neogothic theme of the grandfather who despises all his family leaving his fortune to the youngest of them, the innocent and affectionate Marie (“I’ll be eight on the fifth of June, Gwandpa”).

Parrish, although a little wooden and faux-cultured, makes an appealing heroine; she was one of those actresses whose Hollywood careers never did quite pan out, although she made a mark as the counterpoint to Deanna Durbin in a few movies and with both X Marks the Spot (1931), as a child actress, and the unrelated X MARKS THE SPOT (1942), as the female lead. She died of cancer a few weeks before her 35th birthday.

Dick Purcell, as PI Johnny Smith, is pretty dreadful here, spending much of his time in the first half of the movie laughing uproariously (and falsely) at things that aren’t remotely funny. Later, when he adopts a harder edge, he seems to be trying to channel George Raft. He’s best known for playing the title role in the 15-part serial Captain America (1944).

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 6 Smith, roused from slumber by latest murder

Johnny Smith (Dick Purcell) is roused from slumber by news of the latest murder.

Trail’s novel was earlier brought to the screen as The Thirteenth Guest (1932) dir Albert Ray, with Ginger Rogers and Lyle Talbot; at some stage I’ll get round to watching that version and comment about it here.

If you like the Monogram quickies (and it’s unlikely you’d be on this site if you didn’t like at least some of them), you’ll find a fair amount to enjoy here. But that’s about as much as one can say.

Mystery of the 13th Guest - 9 Burke subtle as hole in road as two lovers smooch

Inspector Burke (Tim Ryan) is as subtle as a hole in road as the two lovers go into the closing smooch.


19 thoughts on “Mystery of the 13th Guest (1943)

  1. Oh,my. your negative comments make me think I’ll give this a miss if it ever comes my way. A shame too, as it sounds like it could have been a reasonable little thriller.

    • It does have its moments — it’s not entirely a waste of time. I’m quite keen to see the 1932 version — it looks to be a somewhat more up-market adaptation.

  2. I haven’t seen this film but I did watch the 1932 version last year. Thought it was reasonably entertaining if a little muddled, a film that I had largely forgotten although reading this post it all came back to me.

    • I’ve got a copy somewhere and must dig it out. Aside from the obvious interest of comparing the two treatments, I always like seeing Rogers in this sort of stuff. I wouldn’t exactly call her a Stanwyck, but she was much more of an actress than many people tend to think, having only ever seen her in light comedy/hoofery.

    • As I’ve just been saying to Jacqui, it’s not worth going out of your way to find but, should it come on telly, it’s not one of those that demand a swift channel-change. It has its moments.

  3. Like Col, I have a feeling that your post is more entertaining than the film itself! That’s no bad thing as I have a watch list of five or six of your recommendations to see. A nice write-up as ever, John. Hope you are enjoying the festive season. 🙂

    • It’s for sure not a movie to go out of your way to find, but at the same time it’s not one of those where you need to dive for the “off” button should it come on tv.

      Hope you are enjoying the festive season.

      Most of the time I don’t even know it’s happening, to be honest (book deadline imminent), except that small children and oafs yell out in public places that I look like Santa and then get upset when I — metaphorically, at least — vomit vengefully on their shoes. I keep wishing I could take them to a World SF Con and watch their brains explode as they see hundreds of people who look like me . . .

  4. Armitage Trailhimself seems interesting. He only wrote two novels – this one and Scarface – and going by the films you couldn’t find more different crime books – and died aged 28.

  5. What an enjoyable way to ring out the old year! So many bad mystery films, so little time! I think the 1932 version plays occasionally on TCM and is vastly superior and different. Even better than that is The Ninth Guest, based on Germ Bristow’s novel, which I think you can still find on You Tube and which is genuinely thrilling. Have you seen that one?

    • So many bad mystery films, so little time!

      That is, I think, the funniest comment here of the year — had me laughing out loud. I know exactly what you mean. Some of them, however bad they are, have great appeal.

      I may be wrong, but I don’t think I have seen The Ninth Guest. Since I have a vile cold that makes “proper” work nigh impossible, I may hie me off to YouTube/Jimbo Berkey’s site in search of it.

  6. “Mystery of the 13th Guest is an anachronistic oddity for 1943 in that it reads like a child of the mid-1930s.”

    Most interesting as is this entire review. You have really turned on your A game here for a fascinating, impassioned piece where you seem to make a recommendation over the issues and inconsistencies. This particular film has never crossed my path. Shame about the score.

  7. Pingback: Detective Kitty O’Day (1944) and Adventures of Kitty O’Day (1945) | Noirish

  8. Pingback: X Marks the Spot (1931) | Noirish

  9. Pingback: Thirteenth Guest, The (1932) | Noirish

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.