Fuchi ni Tatsu (2016)

vt Harmonium
Japan / 120 minutes / color / Comme des Cinémas, Nagoya Broadcasting Network, MAM, Aeon, Elephant House, Asahi Shimbun, Cinémas du Monde, Mountaingate Dir & Scr: Kôji Fukada Pr: Hiroshi Niimura, Yoshito Ohyama, Masa Sawada, Tsuyoshi Toyama Cine: Ken’ichi Negishi Cast: Mariko Tsutsui, Kanji Furutachi, Tadanobu Asano, Taiga, Momone Shinokawa, Kana Mahiro, Takahiro Miura.

An oddly hypnotic piece of Japanese neonoir, presented in two acts that are separated by a period of years.

Toshio (Furutachi) runs a small, independent metalworking company, its staff just him and a succession of apprentices, with his wife Akié (Tsutsui) helping with the accounts. One day, to Akié’s surprise, he suddenly takes on the enigmatic Mr. Yasaka (Asano), an old friend of his whom she’s never met who “just happened to be passing.” We soon learn that Yasaka has recently come out of jail after an eleven-year term served for murder, and it doesn’t take too much deduction to realize that Toshio was somehow implicated in that crime: it’s by way of repaying the debt of silence that Toshio has hired his old acquaintance.

Mariko Tsutsui as Akié.

Yet Yasaka has repented his transgression, and done his best to make amends to the victim’s kin. Akié finds it easy to forgive his past sins, especially since she’s beginning to fall in love with him. Besides, he’s teaching her daughter Hotaru (Shinokawa) to play a new piece on the harmonium for the school concert . . .

Tadanobu Asano as Yasaka.

Eight years later, Hotaru (now played by Mahiro) is a paraplegic and Toshio is still consumed by the desire to track down Yasaka and kill him for having crippled the child in an act of vengeance. He believes, too, that Yasaka seduced Akié; he doesn’t know that part of the reason for Yasaka’s vengeful crime was in retaliation for Akié’s having forcefully refused him. Matters become more complicated when Toshio and Akié discover that the new apprentice, Takashi Yamakami (Taiga), who’s becoming almost a family member, is Yasaka’s estranged illegitimate son.

Momone Shinokawa as Hotaru.

Although this is a movie that’s in large part about the consequences of violence, especially about how those consequences may impact the innocent, there’s almost no violence on screen: just about the only violent act we see is Akié’s rejection of Yasaka’s almost rape-like attempt to have sex with her.

Taiga as Takashi Yamakami.

For me it’s Akié, who along with Hotaru pays the main price for Toshio’s long hypocrisy, who’s the center of this tale. She’s rendered pitch-perfectly by Mariko Tsutsui as effectively two different women separated by eight years of heartbreak that prematurely age her: the term “long-suffering” could have been invented for her. (The makeup department did a splendid job here, too; the older Akié is quite obviously the same woman yet has been “thickened” all over.) Bizarrely, whoever wrote the blurb for the US DVD of Harmonium didn’t think Tsutsui’s name was worth a mention.

Kana Mahiro as the older Hotaru with Mariko Tsutsui as Akié.

Slow-moving yet never lacking in intriguing incident, beautifully paced (just look at the timing in the opening sequence before Hotaru runs back to turn off her metronome, after a gap that’s perfectly judged to allow Mom to tell her to) and superbly photographed (albeit very darkly, at least on the US DVD release), embellished by a nice red herring or two, Harmonium is refreshingly quiet in its approach. I imagine it’ll be a long time before I forget its atmosphere—and Tsutsui’s performance.

4 thoughts on “Fuchi ni Tatsu (2016)

  1. An excellent write-up of a very good film – as you say, the pacing and mood are very finely judged. There’s some very interesting stuff coming out of the far east at moment, Japan in particular.

    Btw, I saw Kore-eda’s Shoplifters at the cinema recently and would definitely recommend it, particularly for the undercurrent of darkness that runs through the narrative. It’s another exploration of the nature of family, albeit more complex and nuanced than some of his earlier films. I think you’d find it an interesting watch!

    • I’m glad you enjoyed this movie too, and thanks for the kind words! I agree with you about the current state of Far Eastern cinema, and keep meaning to watch more of it, but the fact that the movies are almost uniformly on the long side acts against them a bit — especially if I’m planning to write them up for here.

      Thanks for the reminder about Shoplifters. I have it on my mental list of things to watch out for,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.