Floating Dutchman, The (1952)

UK / 76 minutes / bw / Merton Park Dir & Scr: Vernon Sewell Pr: William H. Williams Story: The Floating Dutchman (1950) by Nicolas Bentley Cine: Jo(sef) Ambor Cast: Dermot Walsh, Sydney Tafler, Mary Germaine, Guy Verney, Hugh Morton, Nicolas Bentley, Arnold Marlé, Derek Blomfield, Ian Wilson, James Raglan, Orest Olaff, Ken Midwood.

Floating Dutchman - 0 opener

One never expected masterpieces from Merton Park, but their cut-price fillers did have their charms—they offered an enjoyable way to spend an hour or so even if they tended to be forgotten within minutes of the A-feature starting. The movies in the long EDGAR WALLACE MYSTERIES series (1960–64) were typical of the studio’s output; even at the time it was the series’ theme tune (written by Michael Carr) that really stuck in the mind, far less so the movies themselves. The Floating Dutchman is one of the better Merton Park offerings, and benefits from having the under-recognized Sydney Tafler in a principal role, plus Arnold Marlé and Ian Wilson among the support. And it’s certainly more memorable than many a Merton Park item: I must have been a child when I last saw the movie, because I can remember being devastated by a particular incident toward the end, yet the very fact that, decades later, I could remember this and occasional other incidents—and the performances of Marlé and Wilson—is testament in itself.

Floating Dutchman - 4 Victor

The great Sydney Tafler as club owner and criminal kingpin Victor Skinner.

A body is fished out of the Thames. The cops, as we learn when Inspector Cathie (Morton) briefs his boss, Gwynn (Raglan), swiftly discover that the man died from a bash on the head, not from drowning, and, thanks to an inquiry from the Dutch police, that he was a shady jeweler called Martinus Vandermeer. On the body was a card from the nightclub Skinner’s, with, scrawled on the back, the telephone number of notorious fence Otto Krohner (Marlé). By following up on this link, Cathie believes, the Yard might at last nail the club’s owner, Victor Skinner (Tafler), a criminal kingpin against whom the cops have never been able to make a charge stick.

Floating Dutchman - 2 Otto

Arnold Marlé excels as the sweet-natured fence Otto Krohner.

Cathie seconds Alexander “Alex” James (Walsh), a cop who’s just returned from a two-year assignment in Canada, and instructs him to weasel his way into Victor’s organization, using if need be, for verisimilitude, the identity of a recently emigrated crook, Alan Trevor. When Alex goes to sit in the bar at Skinner’s, he soon makes contact not just with Victor but with one of the taxi dancers, Rose “Rosie” Reid (Germaine). He signals his supposed crookery to Victor by lighting the man’s cigarette with a distinctive cigarette lighter that’s notoriously “hot”, then inveigles himself into Rose’s life by helping her when her brother Phillip (Blomfield), a guitarist in the band at Skinner’s, collapses mid-performance and has to be gotten home.

Phillip is having not just booze problems; he has also “borrowed” a cigarette case from Victor’s latest haul, and both Victor and the fence Otto have noticed its absence. Victor makes it clear to his psycho sidekick Snow White (Verney, in splendidly sinister form) that Phillip has become too much of a risk, and must be got rid of. We never do find out exactly what happens to Phillip; he just sort of disappears from the plot and, while Rose expresses brief perplexity as to his whereabouts, even she doesn’t seem overwhelmingly perturbed.

Floating Dutchman - 3 Phillip

Rosie’s substance-abusing brother Phillip (Derek Blomfield) gets an ultimatum from Skinner (Sydney Tafler).

She has other things on her mind. She and Alex are falling in love, which is welcome to her; less so are Snow White’s insistent attentions. She makes it plain to Snow White that he revolts her, yet whenever she’s around he’s all over her.

Thanks to the good work of Alex and a uniformed copper, PC 276 (Midwood), Inspector Cathie and his sidekick Collis (Bentley) discover how Victor’s gang are pulling off their jewel burglaries. Roffo, the head waiter of a swanky restaurant, is giving Victor the nod when various glittering types are having parties there, so that Victor can be confident of finding their homes empty. The latest tipoff concerns the apartment of socialite Hattie Mason, so round to the woman’s flat go Victor, Snow White and Victor’s new buddy Alex. Because of the shortness of the notice, Alex must ask Rose to phone Mr. Herring (Wilson)—the Charing Cross Road antiquarian bookseller who serves as the undercover Alex’s go-between with his cop colleagues—with a message for Cathie . . . whom she assumes, somewhat miffedly, is a girl.

The cops swoop on Hattie Mason’s flat, catching Victor and, as it were, Alex. Snow White escapes, though, and when he goes back to Skinner’s soon finds out from Harry the barman (Olaff) about the phonecall Rose made. It’s the work of moments to abduct Rose, and . . .

Some of the dialogue—presumably reproduced from the novel—has a sort of genteel faux-hardboiledness that’s priceless; no need for British cargo-cultish “noir” writers like James Hadley Chase and Peter Cheyney to look to their laurels when you have lines like “Birds of a feather should stick together, otherwise they might lose their pants” to bandy. I waited for “What’s a girl like you doing in a joint like Skinner’s?” to come along, and sure enough it did.

Floating Dutchman - 1 Alex and Rose 'What's a girl like you . . .'

Alex (Dermot Walsh) and Rose (Mary Germaine): “What’s a girl like you doing in a joint like Skinner’s?”

Tafler is admirable as the suave crook—you could imagine lending him a fiver without a second thought and then never getting it back—and Marlé offers a truly wonderful performance as the sweet-natured, cat-loving, almost honorable fence Otto, but the most interesting of the movie’s characters is Verney’s Snow White. The man clearly has a serious case of the hots for Rose and seeks to possess her (in every sense; he talks of proprietary rights over her); when Alex moves in and captures her affections, Snow White’s jealousy runs riot. Yet he appears even more jealous over what he perceives as Alex’s purloining of Victor’s affections. There seems definitely a homoerotic undercurrent in the relationship between Snow White and Victor, certainly on Snow White’s side. This makes the final, brilliantly engineered twist in the movie’s tale yet more anguishing for the hoodlum.

Floating Dutchman - 5 Snow White terrifies Rose

Snow White (Guy Verney) calmly terrifies Rose (Mary Germaine).

Nicolas Bentley, who wrote the book upon which this was based and plays the role of Cathie’s subordinate Collis, was of course less well known for his novels than for his illustration work, such as his defining set of illustrations for T.S. Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats (1939). I had the privilege of very briefly making his acquaintance when, towards the end of his life, he supplied illustrations for Richard Ingrams’s Beachcomber: The Works of J.B. Morton (1977), a book on which I did some editorial work.

Floating Dutchman - 6 (for near end) Collis and Alex

Author and illustrator Nicolas Bentley has a supporting role as Sergeant Collis.



The movie’s not on Amazon, but you can find various editions of Bentley’s novel there: The Floating Dutchman.

This entry is part of the 1952 book (and movie) event mounted by Rich Westwood’s Past Offences blog.

9 thoughts on “Floating Dutchman, The (1952)

  1. Always a wonderful thing when a find is made. Must say I am neither familiar with this film, nor have until now read anything that frames it. This is a spirited, wholly riveting read that takes me a long way to negotiating the method to see it. And yes I am a very big fan of Bentley’s illustration for OLD POSSUM’S BOOK FOR PRACTICAL CATS.

    • I wouldn’t say this is a good movie, but it’s certainly an interesting one — for all sorts of reasons. Well worth sparing the time to watch whenever it next turns up on TCM, sort of thing.

  2. Great Post. It makes me wish we had TCM or something similar here in Australia – my brother in the US has it as part of his cable package and I binge when I visit him – but these days it’s difficult to find any movies at all on Australian TV (our cable offerings are not a patch on the US’). I spend a bit on DVDs (precious little in the way of streaming services here either) but there’s a limit to how much I’m prepared to spend on a frivolous category like movies I’m vaguely curious about 🙂

    • Thanks for the kind words.

      always look out for him in films

      Same here! It’s a shame that he seems largely to have dropped off the radar, so far as public awareness is concerned — especially when so many lesser actors of his era are still well recognized. When he turns up in the old Brit noirs he just so often seems to be head-and-shoulders above those around him.

  3. Pingback: Where’s Papa going with that ax? The #1952book challenge | Past Offences Classic Crime Fiction

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.